Kaitlyn first served as the jury moderator for Season 1 - Kanto. When she entered the Johto house, Kaitlyn was immediately nominated by Justin on the Good Team and battled in the first ever battle of the block competition. When she lost alongside Ari, she was lucky enough to survive the first eviction by a wide margin. Kaitlyn coasted through the rest of pre jury until Week 6 when Julia Rae won HoH and nominated her as a pawn during the final eviction before jury. When Julia Rae won the Power of Veto she used it on Kaitlyn and then backdoored Randy successfully. However, during the jury stage of the game, the pawn trend continued for Kaitlyn and she constantly found herself on the block as a final nominee. The second time she was pawned in the jury phase of the game, she was evicted unanimously next to Kaleigh. When the buyback came around, Kaitlyn threw it to Justin with the hope of sending him back into the game to change up the dynamic in the house.