Andie entered the house and immediately gravitated towards working with Corey. A strong duo from the start, the two seemed to have a good handle on what was going on in the house. When Corey was nominated as a backdoor target during Week 2, Andie was one of the main champions for flipping the vote in Corey's favor. Andie worked with the majority mainly for the pre-jury stage of the game, while also having allegiances to Aly and Sydney. The first competition he won was the Week 5 Badge Battle which granted him immunity for the week. Although that didn't have a major impact on the game, it helped Andie to be the next to the last person (besides Rodney) to be nominated. A pivotal moment in Andie's game was when he along with Corey decided to turn on their Final 3 deal with Sydney as a result of Sydney turning on the majority alliance when she decided to keep Nicole safe and nominate Connor and Renee for eviction. Although he didn't put any powers into play that 'ruined' Sydney's Head of Household reign, Sydney felt betrayed by both Corey and Andie. One of the most iconic fights of the season was between Andie and Sydney when she removed him as a contact on Skype. Despite the fallout, Andie was able to make it until Sydney's Head of Household reign during the Fast Forward Eviction without being nominated. When Julia won the Power of Veto, Sydney named him as a replacement nominee, but Andie managed to stay in the house by a vote of 4 to 2. Moving forward, Andie won Head of Household during Week 8 and nominated Sydney and Julio for eviction. This was a controversial move due to the fact that Andie and Corey were aligned with both the Fruit Basket Alliance that consisted of the duo and Julio and Aly as well as their other alliance with Julia and Rodney. When Sydney won the Veto, Andie was forced to choose between Jaly and Rodney and Julia. Ultimately, he decided to turn on Jaly and nominate Aly as a finale nominee next to Julio. Aly won the Head of Household competition the next week and nominated him alongside Julia. When Julia won the Veto, Rodney was the replacement nominee and was ultimately evicted. During the second Fast Forward eviction of the season, Andie won the HOH competition and nominated Sydney alongside Aly. When Corey won the Veto and kept nominations the same, Sydney, Andie's target was evicted. At the Final Four, Andie was nominated by Corey and lost the Veto by a tiebreaker question after completing a dozen video dares, leading to his own eviction at the hands of Aly.